On April 22nd 2016, treasurers from some of Canada’s largest corporate and financial debt issuers gathered at the CFA Society Toronto luncheon to share their experiences in the financial markets and corporate finance. The Overbond team engaged with the industry professionals to uncover key trends and challenges in the fixed income markets.
Experienced Treasurer Panel: Panelists included Ali Suleman (VicePresident & Treasurer) from Hydro One, Max Chan (Director, Treasury) from Enbridge and Peter Levitt (Executive VicePresident & Treasurer) from CIBC. Rob Brown (Co-Head of Debt Capital Markets) from RBC Capital markets moderated the panel discussion.
Treasurers’ Take on the Market: Discussion topics included investor relationship management, price discovery in challenging market environments, borrowing program management, order book allocation, hedging strategies, selecting a syndicate, rating agency relationships, regulatory and legal framework and international market access.
Treasurers stressed the importance of an engaged investor base and actively managing their new issue process to align investors’ goals with the issuers.
Investor Engagement Channels
Investor Engagement: Building and maintaining a robust investor base was top of mind for treasurers. Even for the most established borrowers, active engagement with investors is becoming a prerequisite to run a successful borrowing program. For financial institutions that issue securities with complex structures, such as CIBC, significant time and resources are dedicated to properly educate the institutional investor base. Mr. Suleman mentioned his team’s successful strategy of investing his resources in engaging with smaller fixed income investors, whose typical participation would be in the $1-5 million range. Mr. Suleman added, “sure enough, these investors’ orders grew to $10-20 million over the years as their asset base grew and they gained further comfort on Hydro One’s credit profile.”
Order Book Allocation: Treasurers generally agreed that the allocation process is largely driven by dealers – however, treasurers emphasized the importance of a ‘fairness’ to ensure long term success of their borrowing programs. Mr. Chan stated that he actively ensures that long term supporters who express early interest are rewarded in the allocation process. There seemed to be a conundrum when it came to allocation for “buy and hold” vs. “quick money” investors. It was mentioned that there is a preference towards rewarding long term investors but on the other hand, fast money investors bring value by providing secondary market liquidity.
Secondary market liquidity continues to be challenging.
Reverse inquiries are a critical component of the price discovery process.
|Liquidity Provider||GoC Bonds||CMBs||Provincial Bonds||CTB||Money Market||CAD IRS||Canada||USA||Europe|
|Bank of America Merrill Lynch||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓|
|BMO Capital Markets||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓|
|Casgain & Company Ltd.||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓|
|CIBC World Markets||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓|
|Desjardins Capital Markets||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓|
|National Bank Financial||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓|
|RBC Capital Markets||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓||✓|
Navigating Low Secondary Market Liquidity Environment: Even though new regulations were introduced to encourage greater transparency, the low liquidity nature of fixed income markets presents challenges in price discovery for issuers – sizeable secondary trade points, although scarce, are a valuable source of information for the price discovery process.
Mr. Chan stated “secondary trade points are no longer a great indicator of primary levels (given the lack of liquidity), it is just another data point”.
Reverse Inquiries: It was loud and clear that reverse inquiry, an inquiry a potential investor makes to a corporate issuer about purchasing a particular debt security, is a critical component in gaining comfort on investor demand for issuer’s credit and their price discovery process.
Treasurers mentioned that they closely track reverse inquiries received, either indirectly through dealers or directly from investors, and often reward those investors for expressing their interest and commitment.
“Transparency in the fixed income market is generally limited because it is a negotiated market.
Despite significant advances in technology, many bond trades are still completed over the phone.
This has hindered the growth of electronic trading platforms and made it more difficult to
– The Canadian Fixed Income Market, Ontario Securities Commission1
Each corporation had different mandates and objectives, and employs a variety of strategies to optimize cost of funding.
1. Maturity Smoothing: Ladder maturities based on portfolio approach. Issuers can also set limits on the total amount of bonds coming due in a single year to reduce concentration of refinancing risk.
2. Yield Curve: Add shorter tenors to take advantage of steep yield curve. Issuers with longer asset life can finance a portion of their debt with shorter maturities and refinance them periodically to achieve lower cost of funding.
3. Interest Rate Hedging: Lock in low underlying rates using financial instruments such as forward contracts.
4. Issuance Timing: Actively monitor rate and credit spread movements to make informed decisions. Also issuers with larger borrowing program can divide their borrowing needs into sequenced tranches to achieve natural rates diversification.
5.International Markets: Actively seek ‘arbitrage’ opportunities to issue in foreign market and swap proceeds back to achieve lower overall cost of funding.
More on Interest Rate Hedging: Interest rate hedging policies varied amongst the treasurers – no hedging to active hedging through forward contracts. Key challenges of interest rate hedging were accounting and tax treatments of hedge gains and losses that may be unique to some of the issuers.
One treasurer stated that he does not make speculative market calls. Instead, he ensures that the rates they achieve meets his firm’s internal cost of funding targets.
Forecasts by established economists are used to understand the rate environment to make educated decisions.
Rate hedging is challenging given the low interest rate environments where credit spreads, an exposure that cannot readily be hedged, have become a significant component of overall funding costs.
It is important to manage relationships with multiple stakeholders, including dealer syndicates, regulators, rating agencies and legal counsel.
|Rank||Bookrunner||Amount ($M)||Market Share (% )||# of Deals|
|1||RBC Capital Markets||13,560||29.2||82|
|2||CIBC World Markets Inc||8,102||17.5||47|
|3||TD Securities Inc||6,441||13.9||39|
|4||BMO Capital Markets||6,036||13||42|
|6||National Bank of Canada||3,104||6.7||22|
|7||HSBC Holdings PLC||1,221||2.6||6|
|8||Bank of America Merrill Lynch||1,099||2.4||7|
|9||Desjardins Securities Inc||472||1||3|
|10||Casgrain & Companies Ltee||126||0.3||2|
|△ Since Last Year||-14%||-19%|
Syndicate Selection Treasurers discussed the factors involved in determining syndicate structure. Mr. Levitt utilizes the three C’s approach:
Rating Agencies All treasurers emphasized the importance of prompt and transparent disclosure of information to help rating agencies better understand their credit profiles. The level of engagement has become increasingly important after the 2008 - 2009 financial crisis.
Regulatory Framework Canadian regulators are actively engaged with the industry to provide practical regulatory updates and promote a stable financial environment.
Issuers work closely with their legal counsel to navigate through changing regulatory environment. One example is changes to prospectus marketing rules. Issuer also stressed the importance of working with counsel to meet all compliance requirements such as black-out periods while preserving flexibility to take advantage of favorable market conditions.
International Markets Considerations In addition to the potential ‘arbitrage’ funding opportunities presented by foreign debt capital markets, treasurers stated a few key benefits in
Overbond brings all bond market participants together. It is a platform that makes primary bond issuance digital, transparent and secure. Overbond connects corporate and government issuers with dealers and investors directly.
Vuk Magdelinic | CEO
+1 (416) 559-7101